NEW YORK'S MOST UNUSUAL STORE

We Search the Greatest City in the World for Hard-to-Find Products and Gifts

Soda Fountain

  • Two 2-Piece Classic 1950s-Era Soda Fountain Service Sets (Stainless Steel Holders with Bell-Shaped Glasses)
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $49.00
  • 24 Classic 1950s-Era Soda Fountain Bell-Shaped Beverage Glasses
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $0.00
  • 24 Classic 1950s-Era Soda Fountain Stainless-Steel Handled Holders
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $0.00

Objects + Artifacts

  • Original and Authentic Toots Shor Ashtray
    Regular price
    $600.00
    Sale price
    $600.00
  • "The Plaza Cookbook" Rare 1972 First Edition
    Regular price
    $90.00
    Sale price
    $90.00
  • Original Luchow's German Restaurant "Beer Stein" Ashtray
    Regular price
    $195.00
    Sale price
    $195.00
  • "The Colony Cookbook" 1972 First Edition
    Regular price
    $45.00
    Sale price
    $45.00
  • The Plaza Hotel Tin Replica, Vintage Souvenir
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $100.00
  • "Toots" by Bob Considine, Collectible 1969 Edition
    Regular price
    $95.00
    Sale price
    $95.00
  • Rare "Arthur" Disco-Era Ashtray
    Regular price
    $250.00
    Sale price
    $250.00
  • Original Russian Tea Room Ashtray PLUS Faith Stewart-Gordon's "Love Story"
    Regular price
    $145.00
    Sale price
    $145.00

The NEW YORK FIRST Company was founded in 1995 in Ithaca, New York.